Faster, Cheaper, Better? What Generative AI Really Delivers in Innovation Foresight

Creators: Wild, Antje and Brehm, Hanna and Volk-Schor, Carina and Stadler, Dorothee and Kröger, Niclas
Title: Faster, Cheaper, Better? What Generative AI Really Delivers in Innovation Foresight
Item Type: Conference or Workshop Item
Event Title: (Proceedings of the) XXXVII ISPIM Innovation Conference “Connecting for Innovation”
Event Location: Granada, Spain
Event Dates: June, 7-10, 2026
Date: July 2026
Divisions: Informationsmanagement
Abstract (ENG): Innovation foresight is strategically critical yet resource-intensive, limiting its adoption especially among smaller firms. This study examines which stages of the foresight process generative AI can substitute for expert-driven foresight without compromising quality, and with what cost-time trade-offs. We conducted an end-to-end innovation foresight process for a multinational garden equipment firm, comparing outputs from a professional human expert team against those of AI models (ChatGPT, Claude, Copilot-Premium, Copilot-Standard) under two prompting conditions. Four independent expert judges evaluated all outputs blind using stage-specific quality criteria. Results reveal a stage-dependent pattern: AI achieves quality parity with human experts at trend identification and innovation field stages, while humans substantially outperform AI at the scenario development stage, with the largest effects on novelty and organizational specificity. These quality differences must be read alongside dramatic efficiency gains: AI completed the process saving 98.70% of time and 99.27% of cost.
Forthcoming: No
Language: English
Uncontrolled Keywords: Innovation foresight; generative AI; corporate foresight; scenario planning; trend identification; strategic innovation fields; task–technology fit; jagged technological frontier; prompting strategies; human–AI collaboration
Link eMedia: Download
Citation:

Wild, Antje and Brehm, Hanna and Volk-Schor, Carina and Stadler, Dorothee and Kröger, Niclas (2026) Faster, Cheaper, Better? What Generative AI Really Delivers in Innovation Foresight. In: (Proceedings of the) XXXVII ISPIM Innovation Conference “Connecting for Innovation”, June, 7-10, 2026, Granada, Spain.

Actions for admins (login required)

View Item in edit mode (academic staff only) View Item in edit mode (academic staff only)